Guides and reviews of vacuum tubes and audio equipment
5751 Tube Reviews
The 5751 is a ruggedized, low-noise relative of the 12AX7 with about 70 percent of its gain, an amplification factor near 70 instead of 100. Because the pinout is identical, many listeners use it in place of a 12AX7 to tame excess gain or noise in phono stages, preamps and guitar amplifiers.
The GE JAN 5751 three-mica and Sylvania and RCA versions are the best known. Below are our listening reviews of 5751s with reader star ratings. See also our 12AX7 reviews and tube equivalents guide.
Update, November 2026: Tube Maze now keeps live 12AX7 rankings that update automatically as readers vote. See the current 12AX7 tube ratings, or compare every type on Top Tubes. This article is kept as originally written in 2020.
Which 12ax7/5751 tube won the right to be called the best and the worst?
Sound:, my listening impressionClearSlightly clear,·SpaciousSlightly spacious,·DynamicSlightly dynamic
The Arcturus 5751 Black Plates D-getter is a very rare tube with truly unique sonic qualities. Initially, my expectations were modest because Arcturus transitioned to rebranding other manufacturers’ valves after 1952. However, upon inspection, it was immediately clear that this was no ordinary 5751; it featured long shiny black plates and a distinct bent D-getter.
Sound:, my listening impressionBalancedBalanced tone,·SpaciousSlightly spacious,·DynamicDynamic
The Raytheon 5751 Black Plates Triple Mica is a tube that truly needs no introduction, as it is very smooth, very dynamic, and quite simply very everything. This is definitively one of the leaders in the pack of “super 5751s,” holding its own against the absolute best in the category. While I still prefer the Sylvania JHS or GB 5751 by a tiny margin, that preference might be entirely psychological. Considering this tube sells for only 30-40% of what the Gold Brand version commands, it represents an incredible value, you shouldn’t wait, get it now.
Sound:, my listening impressionBalancedBalanced tone,·SpaciousSpacious,·DynamicSlightly dynamic
This is a very good tube, it’s actually the best GE tube that I’ve heard :). You get very good bass and mid-range, along with a very good soundstage and great details. It is a 5-Star performer after all. In a blind test that I performed, the GE 5751 5 Stars Black Plates was indistinguishable from the Sylvania JHS 5751, even the construction of the two tubes is extremely similar with only a few differences. Rolling this tube again through another amp proved once more that it is superb, as the sound between these black plates and the JHS or RCA versions is incredibly similar, with only the Gold Brand gray plates standing out from the bunch. This is a very good, very transparent tube.
Sound:, my listening impressionWarmWarm,·SpaciousSlightly spacious,·DynamicSlightly dynamic
The Tung-Sol 5751 Long Gray Plates is a tube I’ve been eager to spotlight for quite some time, and for good reason. In the crowded landscape of 12AX7 and 5751 variants, this particular piece stands out not just for its thicker mica and unique aesthetic, but for a sonic profile that defines the word “liquid.” While many tubes treat notes like a binary—on or off—the Tung-Sol allows them to flow into one another like water being poured between glasses.
For those familiar with high-fidelity vacuum tubes, the Sylvania 5751 JHS and Gold Brand (GB) triple-mica variants are often regarded as the industry standard for audio performance. While collectors frequently prioritize the JHS black-plate or GB gray-plate versions for their aesthetic appeal—notably the gold pins and lettering—audiophiles seeking superior sound quality can achieve the same results at a significantly lower price point. By looking beyond the premium branding, it is possible to acquire these tubes for approximately $20 to $25, compared to the $100 market rate for “Gold” labeled versions.
Sound:, my listening impressionClearSlightly clear,·SpaciousSlightly spacious,·DynamicDynamic
It’s so nice and surprising to have GE tube that actually sounds quite good. This 5-Star 5751 triple mica with Gray plates – sounds very similar to its older Black Plates brother. The sound quality is very high. Bass maybe not as tight as Black, but I felt it’s more controlled. As with all Gray Plates, this tube has better transparency and dynamics than black plates, but HF is not as sweet. Overall a very natural sounding tube. Recommended.
Sound:, my listening impressionClearSlightly clear,·BalancedBalanced soundstage,·DynamicVery dynamic
As one of the most legendary vacuum tubes to come out of the United States, the Raytheon 5751 Black Plate with the Windmill Getter is a piece of hardware that arrives with massive expectations. These are becoming increasingly difficult to source, and after finally securing a set, I put them through their paces. Initially, I was a bit underwhelmed; when tested through my Dared and McIntosh amplifiers, the soundstage felt somewhat compressed compared to the Raytheon 5751 BP 3-Mica, and the midrange lacked that signature “luscious” sweetness found in the Sylvania Gold Brand. The highs weren’t quite as extended as other top-tier tubes, leading me to give it a cautious 4.5-star rating.
Sound:, my listening impressionWarmWarm,·SpaciousSpacious,·DynamicDynamic
This Ken-Rad 12AX7 Black Plate is a truly fascinating vintage find. It delivers a remarkably warm and deep sonic profile, reminiscent of a rich, dark cup of coffee, paired with an expansive soundstage that draws you in. Sonically, it shares a striking resemblance to the sought-after RCA 12AX7 carbon plates.
Sound:, my listening impressionClearSlightly clear,·BalancedBalanced soundstage,·BalancedBalanced dynamics
The GE 5751 Gray Plates are good tubes that offer great high-frequency extension and a solid bass foundation. While they are definitely not as good as Telefunken smooth or ribbed plates in terms of high-frequency extension, and not as sweet in the midrange as the Sylvania Gold Brand 5751, they have the advantage of costing much less and being much easier to find. These characteristics make them a great everyday tube for consistent listening.