Top-rated 12AU7s

  1. Mullard 12AU7 Long Plates Mitcham5.0 · 4 votes
  2. BEL 12AU7 Short Plates India4.8 · 4 votes
  3. Brimar 12AU7 Clear Top Gray Plates4.7 · 6 votes
  4. Sylvania CHS 5963 Gray Plates4.5 · 8 votes
  5. Mullard 12AU7 Short Gray Plates4.5 · 4 votes

Ranked by reader star ratings (3+ votes).

Brimar 12AU7 Clear Top Gray Plates

Brimar 12AU7 Clear Top Gray Plates

(6 votes, average: 4.67 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Slightly clear, Spacious, Balanced dynamics

These are some beautiful, very rare tubes. The Brimar 12AU7 Clear Top with gray plates is one of those valves you almost never see come up, and when it does, most people walk right past it; because at a glance it looks just like an RCA 12AU7 Clear Top. Same clear upper glass, same gray plate structure. But they are not RCAs, and once you know what to look for, the differences are obvious.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

Valvo ECC186/7316/12AU7 Holland

Valvo ECC186/7316/12au7 Holland

(50 votes, average: 4.06 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Balanced tone, Slightly spacious, Slightly relaxed

The Amperex ECC186/7316 is widely considered the absolute pinnacle of the 12AU7 family, and after spending some time with it, I can say the reputation is well-deserved. If you are looking for the “final” upgrade for your preamp, this is likely it.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

GE JG-5814 Black Flat Plates

GE JG-5814 Black Flat Plates

(38 votes, average: 4.11 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Balanced tone, Spacious, Dynamic

This particular GE JG-5814 is an incredibly rare find, likely produced during the narrow transitionary period between 1952 and 1953. Before this window, all 5814 production featured carbon plates. Moving into late 1953, GE shifted toward the more common triple mica construction with shiny black plates. This “Black Flat Plate” variant represents the best of both worlds.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

Brimar 6067/12AU7 Black Plates

Brimar 6067/12AU7 Black Plates

(37 votes, average: 4.14 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Slightly clear, Spacious, Slightly dynamic

The Brimar 6067 stands as one of the rarest “Special Type” valves ever to leave the United Kingdom. While the market is flooded with 6067 variants—some of which aren’t even authentic Brimar production—the genuine Black Plate version is a masterclass in vacuum tube engineering.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

Sylvania Gold Brand GB-5814A/12AU7 Long Gray Plates

Sylvania Gold Brand GB-5814/12au7 Long Gray Plates

(31 votes, average: 3.97 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Slightly clear, Spacious, Dynamic

The Sylvania Gold Brand line wasn’t just another marketing label; it was engineered as a premium tier for critical industrial and commercial applications. While there are at least four known versions of the 5814 tube, this Long Gray Plate variant stands out for its incredible durability and specialized internals.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

Tung-Sol 6189/ECC82/12AU7W Russia

Tung-Sol 6189/ECC82/12AU7W tube - Russia

(18 votes, average: 3.39 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Slightly warm, Slightly spacious, Balanced dynamics

Despite the hype and a wave of positive reviews, my experience with the Tung-Sol 6189/ECC82 was a bit of a letdown. While it offers a smooth sound profile, it definitely lacks the magic of the “vintage” Tung-Sol era. The soundstage is notably wide, yet it fails to achieve that sought-after holographic depth.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

Mullard 12AU7/ECC82 Reissue Russia

Mullard 12au7/ECC82 Reissue Russia

(10 votes, average: 3.30 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Slightly warm, Balanced soundstage, Balanced dynamics

This review has been a long time coming, though I admit I kept pushing it off for another day. Dealing with the Mullard 12AU7/ECC82 Reissue is a bit of a nostalgia trip, even if the reality is firmly rooted in modern manufacturing.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

CBS-Hytron 5814A – Engineering Samples

CBS-Hytron 5814A – Engineering Samples

Once in a while, while going through a new shipment of tubes, I find some true treasures. This time it was an incredible find, the legendary CBS-Hytron 5814 tubes, but not just that, they were engineering samples from CBS-Hytron. Engineering samples were sent to various manufacturers to get acceptance and determine interest before starting mass production. Unfortunately, there is no date code on the box or the tubes, so it’s hard to say when it was produced exactly, but considering that 5814 tubes have been produced since October 1949, these are not far behind. Notice, that there is not 5814 label on the glass, just on the wrapper.

I’ve already written about these tubes and there are also posts about comparing them to other tubes from other contributors.

Share this post:

Favorite Tubes 12AU7

Update, November 2026: Tube Maze now keeps live 12AU7 rankings that update automatically as readers vote. See the current 12AU7 tube ratings, or compare every type on Top Tubes. This article is kept as originally written in 2018.

Hi there, I’ve now listened and analyzed countless 12au7’s (and it’s equivalents) and thought I’d give my opinion on my current favorites.

1st Place Tie: Mazda 6189 Silver Plates 3-Mica and 50’s Valvo Long Plate Angled Getter

These are somewhat similar to me in that they both have soaring/sparkling top-ends and beautiful midrange. Both have lots of detail. I think Mazda has better bass and is slightly more precise, forward and transparent. But Mazda is also more dry. Valvo is sexier and easier on the ears. To me, the Valvos are a bit light on the bass. Mazdas have maybe a larger soundstage, but Valvo is deeper and more intimate. Tie for first. If someone put a gun to my head, I’d choose the Valvos.

Continue reading →
Share this post: