Ei 12AX7 Long Gray Plates

Ei 12AX7 Long Gray Plates

(8 votes, average: 3.13 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Slightly warm, Slightly intimate, Balanced dynamics

The Ei 12AX7 Long Gray Plates are a fascinating piece of audio history, often riding the coattails of the legendary Telefunken Smooth Plates. Since these were manufactured on the same physical machinery as their German counterparts, the hype is understandable. Visually, they are almost twins, though a keen eye will spot the differences: the Ei plates have a center opening rather than a top one, a flat crossbar for the heater ground, and a simple round getter instead of the Telefunken’s flat halo.

Continue reading →

Share this post:

Raytheon 5751 Black Plates, Windmill

Raytheon 5751 Black Plates, Windmill

(14 votes, average: 3.93 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Slightly clear, Balanced soundstage, Very dynamic

As one of the most legendary vacuum tubes to come out of the United States, the Raytheon 5751 Black Plate with the Windmill Getter is a piece of hardware that arrives with massive expectations. These are becoming increasingly difficult to source, and after finally securing a set, I put them through their paces. Initially, I was a bit underwhelmed; when tested through my Dared and McIntosh amplifiers, the soundstage felt somewhat compressed compared to the Raytheon 5751 BP 3-Mica, and the midrange lacked that signature “luscious” sweetness found in the Sylvania Gold Brand. The highs weren’t quite as extended as other top-tier tubes, leading me to give it a cautious 4.5-star rating.

Continue reading →

Share this post:

Electro-Harmonix 12AX7

Electro-Harmonix 12AX7

(6 votes, average: 3.00 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Balanced tone, Balanced soundstage, Balanced dynamics

The Electro-Harmonix 12AX7 often receives glowing reviews on various platforms, particularly on retail sites, but personal testing reveals a far less exciting reality. While it is an affordable option, it lacks any truly interesting or engaging sonic characteristics, making it feel remarkably boring when compared to available NOS alternatives. Even when kept as a spare set for high-end equipment like a McIntosh 275, the performance fails to impress, as there are many vintage tubes at a similar price point that offer significantly better sound quality.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

Raytheon 12AX7 Black Plates

Raytheon 12AX7 Black Plates

(32 votes, average: 3.78 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Balanced tone, Intimate, Slightly dynamic

The Raytheon 12AX7 Black Plates is a tube that often receives great reviews, but personally, I didn’t find it particularly interesting for home audio use. While it is rumored to sound great in guitar amplifiers, it performed only okay in a McIntosh setup, offering a very controlled and tight bass with good warmth but nothing truly special. It simply doesn’t compare well with industry leaders like Telefunken, Mullard, or Sylvania Gold Brand, as the soundstage feels a bit compressed in comparison. Though the bass and high frequencies are present, I found the highs to be a bit sharp, and surprisingly, this is the first black plate I’ve encountered that sounded too much like the gray plates I typically dislike. Overall, the presentation was a bit too “in your face” for my preference.

Continue reading →

Share this post:

Mazda 12AX7 Chrome Plates

Mazda 1959 Chrome Plate France

(25 votes, average: 3.44 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Clear, Very spacious, Dynamic

Upon testing the Mazda 12AX7 Silver/Chrome Plate, I was immediately struck by its performance, especially since documentation on this specific variant is so scarce. My particular specimen is a rare 1958 production featuring a circular hole in the plate rather than the standard slit.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

Ken-Rad 12AX7 Black Plates

Ken-Rad 12ax7 Black Plates

(9 votes, average: 3.67 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Warm, Spacious, Dynamic

This Ken-Rad 12AX7 Black Plate is a truly fascinating vintage find. It delivers a remarkably warm and deep sonic profile, reminiscent of a rich, dark cup of coffee, paired with an expansive soundstage that draws you in. Sonically, it shares a striking resemblance to the sought-after RCA 12AX7 carbon plates.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

Telefunken 12AX7 Smooth Plates

Telefunken 12ax7 smooth plates

(12 votes, average: 4.08 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Clear, Very spacious, Slightly dynamic

The Telefunken 12AX7 Smooth Plates is a high-stakes component that can either transform or unbalance your entire audio system. When I tested these in a Dared 300B, the results were merely acceptable, primarily because that amplifier already leans toward the brighter side of the spectrum. However, the experience changed completely when I rolled them into a McIntosh 275.

Continue reading →
Share this post:

GE 12AX7 Gray Plates

GE 12AX7 Gray Plates

(6 votes, average: 2.67 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Clear, Slightly intimate, Balanced dynamics

The GE 12AX7 Gray Plates is not a bad tube, however, I find them a bit sharp on the top, which seems to be true for the majority of GE tubes. The highs are definitely not as sweet as some other tubes, such as the RCA 5751, but if no other NOS options are available, I would use it.

Continue reading →

Share this post:

GE 5751 Gray Plates

GE 5751 Gray Plates

(12 votes, average: 3.00 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Slightly clear, Balanced soundstage, Balanced dynamics

The GE 5751 Gray Plates are good tubes that offer great high-frequency extension and a solid bass foundation. While they are definitely not as good as Telefunken smooth or ribbed plates in terms of high-frequency extension, and not as sweet in the midrange as the Sylvania Gold Brand 5751, they have the advantage of costing much less and being much easier to find. These characteristics make them a great everyday tube for consistent listening.

Continue reading →

Share this post:

Sylvania 5751 Gold Brand Gray Plates Triple Mica

Sylvania 5751 Gold Brand Gray Plates

(13 votes, average: 4.23 out of 5)

Sound:, my listening impression Balanced tone, Spacious, Slightly dynamic

The Sylvania 5751 Gold Brand is a genuinely fascinating vacuum tube that defies standard expectations. Having previously relied on the RCA 5751 triple mica, I anticipated a similar performance, but the Sylvania Gold Brand series offers a completely different sonic profile. When paired with a McIntosh 275, it introduces a new dimension to the listening experience, characterized by an immense warmth and a lush, intimate soundstage.

Continue reading →
Share this post: